Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Fifty Before '50: JIMMY

 by JB

This Fathom Events release is like a Hallmark movie... if Christmas and World War II were the same thing.

I was excited earlier this year to learn that specialty distributor Fathom Events (Excuse me, Fathom Entertainment) was going into the movie production game. Their first original production? Jimmy—a sure-fire, old-fashioned biopic on American movie icon James Stewart. This seemed a calculated move: older people are one of the last remaining demographics who still go out to the movies, and one of the last remaining demographics who still remember Jimmy Stewart. The film focuses on Stewart’s WWII service as a bomber pilot, also garnering Fathom the coveted demographic of retired Dads obsessed with WWII. The film takes place in a fanciful recreation of the 1940s, which, based on the last twelve years, is an era (Era.) to which some Americans yearn to return. What could possibly go wrong?

Turns out, plenty.
THE PLOT IN BRIEF: It’s 1941, and Jimmy Stewart (KJ Apa, doing an over-the-top but serviceable impression) has just won the Best Actor Oscar for The Philadelphia Story.
TRIVIA NOTE: Historians agree that Stewart’s performance in The Philadelphia Story was a supporting role. Stewart always thought he won because he was denied the statue the year before for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. MGM head Louis B. Meyer (Jason Alexander) has big plans for Stewart in his movies, but then Pearl Harbor is bombed and Stewart wants to join the Air Force.

Stewart serves honorably in the Air Force, piloting more than twenty missions and earning the Distinguished Flying Cross, the Air Medal with three oak clusters, and a promotion to Colonel. He has a brief affair with Lady Julia (Kara Killmer) but that does not go well, and Stewart returns home. Hollywood is a very different place in 1946, but luckily old pal Frank Capra (Max Casella) wants Stewart to star in his new film It’s a Wonderful Life, thus ensuring Stewart’s legacy.
NEVER MIND that Louis B. Mayer made more money loaning Stewart out to other studios than he ever made with him during his seven years at MGM. The studio never really figured out what to do with Jimmy; the most egregious example was Born to Dance, where he was forced to sing and dance with Eleanor Powell. You remember "Jimmy Stewart, singing sensation"? Of course you don't. Nobody does.

Lady Julia is almost certainly a composite character; Stewart reportedly had scads of romantic liaisons while serving in England. Though the film hints that Stewart dated Ginger Rogers and Olivia de Havilland in Hollywood, “Lothario Jimmy” has no place in this reverent hagiography. (In real life, Stewart also had affairs with Norma Shearer, Loretta Young, Marlene Dietrich, Lana Turner, Dorothy Lamour, and Joan Fontaine! As Stewart himself would probably say, “Well, Gosh!”)

In the film’s most risible scene, Stewart just can’t nail down the right emotion while filming the scene in Wonderful Life where he prays to God in Martini’s bar. This scene requires Stewart to call upon his faith... and his faith has been severely tested in the war. After a pep talk from director Capra, Stewart tries again and... WITH THE HELP OF THE GHOSTS OF HIS DEAD WAR BUDDIES, WHO SUDDENLY ALL APPEAR BEHIND THE CAMERA, EGGING HIM ON... he nails the scene! Just the way it no doubt actually happened in 1946.
ON THE PLUS SIDE: The film’s recreation of Hollywood in the 1940s is spot-on and meticulous. The costume, make-up, hair styling, location scouting, set-building, production design, and cinematography departments should all take a collective bow. The film is handsome, with deep, saturated hues like those of early Technicolor. (Though some of the CGI aviation footage is a little janky.) Jason Alexander’s take on LB Mayer is a hoot. Christopher McDonald plays Lionel Barrymore without shaving his head. The film is only two hours long.

THE CRITICS RAVE: The AV Club’s Monica Castillo called the film “disrespectful and cheap,” Dennis Schwartz called it “safe, dull, and uninspiring,” The Hollywood Reporter’s Frank Scheck described it as “ploddingly dutiful,” The Movie State’s Matt Gillam used the terms “generic” and “monotonous,” and Peter Travers called the film “safe and sorry.”

William Bibbiani, writing in The Wrap, summarizes this biopic’s peculiar imbecility best: “It’s always tough when a movie, especially a movie as fawning and fake as Jimmy, demands that you accept its reality by declaring it’s not a film. It’s even worse when the filmmakers double down by having this Julia person ask Stewart 'We’re real, aren’t we?'... No, she’s not real... which makes her exactly the wrong person to break the fourth wall by declaring there’s no fourth wall."
Thank God director Aaron Burns and screenwriter Justin Strawhand didn’t ever break the fourth wall again in this corny and predictable yarn. I fear that even more ghostly aviators would come pouring out of that break, waving US flags, singing “God Bless America,” and selling war bonds while insisting that George Baily was not responsible for their untimely deaths.

See Jimmy if you love Jimmy Stewart and Jesus and Ghosts.

No comments:

Post a Comment