by Patrick Bromley
Ten times I got it wrong.It's very difficult to make a Top 10 list at the end of each year, not because I have a hard time finding 10 movies I liked (though sometimes that's true) but because I don't always know how I'm really going to feel about a movie until I live with it for a while. A lot of the movies on this list are growers and movies I've seen more and like more than most of the titles I wound up putting on my lists.
Gone Girl (2014, dir. David Fincher)I still remember going to see Gone Girl in 2014 (it was a rare instance of Erika and I both bringing our moms to see it) and struggling with what I found to be its messy politics. It wasn't the Amy stuff -- I understood her narrative and thematic purpose -- but a bunch of stuff surrounding that character that made me feel like the movie was really siding with the Ben Affleck character against all women. I've watched it quite a few times since then and don't have that same reaction, probably because I'm no longer a fucking idiot (I am still a fucking idiot). This movie is brilliant and arguably the best-cast movie of the 2000s. It went from not being in my Top 10 to being one of my favorites of its decade and one of my top three David Fincher films.
Widows (2018, dir. Steve McQueen)There may have been some reluctance on my part to include Widows on my Top 10 because I saw it as little more than a studio genre exercise done well. Now that's exactly what I love about it. I've never been above putting genre stuff on my list, but it's usually lower budget and more forthright about being genre stuff (see: Turbo Kid). Widows is A-list across the board, from the cast to being directed by one of the most acclaimed filmmakers currently working, so it hides its genre trappings a little more. If it were made as an exploitation movie in the 1970s I'd be rightly calling it a great work of art, so why shouldn't I have in 2018?
Miami Vice (2006, dir. Michael Mann)My love of Miami Vice is well-known and well-documented around these parts. I only liked it when I saw it in 2006, and it wasn't until I revisited it on DVD a year or so later that I completely flipped for it from its opening frames (this would have been the theatrical cut, of course). Now it's not just my favorite movie of 2006, but my favorite Michael Mann movie and one of my favorite movies full stop. I'd like to believe I was leading the charge on this one's reappraisal just a little but I'm realistic and honest with myself enough to know that no one listens to me.
The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017, dir. Yorgos Lanthimos)This was the movie that started turning me around on Greek filmmaker Yorgo Lanthimos, who has since been such a grower for me that I'd count him as one of my favorite directors currently working now. That was not originally the case. I found his work too mannered and same-y. I get it; everyone is flat and dispassionate. But then I saw Killing of a Sacred Deer and the absolute brutality of its dark, dark comedy knocked me over in such a way that I couldn't dismiss it. I've loved everything he's done since -- both Poor Things and Bugonia both rightly made it into my Top 10s (Kinds of Kindness did not, which I'd also like to amend) -- but because this is the one that first left me Yorgos Pilled, I wanted to recognize it as part of this list.
Tenet (2020, dir. Christopher Nolan)2020 was such a normal time for movies and life in general. I didn't get to see Tenet in theaters as Christopher Nolan intended for reasons I can't possibly recall but I did blind buy it and watch it the day it was released on Blu-ray. That year, the best I could manage was to put it on my 'underrated' list. I loved the vibes but found the story inscrutable. Both of those things are still true today, but now I realize the plot doesn't matter and it's all vibes. This has become one of my favorite Christopher Nolan movies for that reason, and while I don't think I would call it my favorite film of 2020 (Da 5 Bloods still exists and needs a disc release), I'd probably put it at number 2 now. This was also the movie that made me think Robert Pattinson should play James Bond. That worked out well for both of us.
Lady Bird (2017, dir. Greta Gerwig)This is the movie that inspired me to make this list. I liked Lady Bird back in 2017 in a very "first movie" kind of way, but I don't know that I saw past its charm to just how nuanced and accomplished it really is. I showed it in class maybe a year ago and finally had my Magic Screening in which I completely fell in love with the movie and just how perfectly it captures what Billy Wilder calls the Sour and the Sweet not just of adolescence, but of parenthood, of friendship, of life. The movie is indebted to The 400 Blows, so it's no wonder I now love it as much as I do.
Burn After Reading (2008, dir. Joel Coen)I know this is "minor" Coens, but goddamn if it isn't a brilliant black comedy about stupid people caught up in a situation they don't understand. The ensemble cast is hilarious and the movie only gets funnier the more times you see it. Truth be told, this doesn't even make my Top 10 Coens I'm guessing, but 2008 was not the best year for movies and I didn't think too badly of my list when I looked at it. Still, this one should have had a place on it.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011, dir. David Fincher)Like Tenet, this is a vibes movie except the vibes are bad. I didn't love it in 2011, but like some other movies on this list it's something to which I kept getting drawn back. Eventually I had to face facts that it had become a fucked up comfort movie for me and might sneak into the #5 slot of my favorite David Finchers. This is, in some ways, the David Fincherest of the David Finchers because his movies are all about, as Rob says, liars and perverts.
Dune Part 1 (2021, dir. Denis Villeneuve)Another movie that got a weird release because of the time in which it came out, meaning I first saw it on HBO Max before going to see it theatrically later the same week. I think I was reading the book at the same time, which probably didn't help my reaction even though I was really positive towards the movie. I revisited it in anticipation of the second installment and realized I had fucked up not putting it in my Top 10 for that year because it ruuuuules. I didn't repeat the mistake when Part 2 came out and that wound up on my list. I suspect the third one will too. I can't wait.
Avatar (2009, dir. James Cameron)No surprises here. Back in 2009, I put District 9 on my list. I've rewatched it exactly 0 times. I've seen Avatar like 10 times since then. I'm the worst.
.jpeg)









Sacred Deer is right where I started to turn off on Lantimos. I'm sure why. I liked the movie enough, but after it, i was never in a rush to see his new stuff
ReplyDelete